Best Mystery Anime of All Time

Ranked by community ratings from MyAnimeList across 561 mystery titles spanning 1990–present.

1
David Production · 2026 · 109,171 ratings
Audience opinion is sharply divided, primarily between those deeply disappointed by the anime adaptation's perceived...
9
2
Madhouse · 2004 · 501,858 ratings
Audience opinions on Monster are divided. While many praise its intricate story, well-developed characters, and...
8.9
3
OLM · 2025 · 239,426 ratings
Audience sentiment is divided. Some viewers found Season 2 to be a superior continuation with rewarding plotlines and...
8.9
4
Shaft · 2017 · 295,692 ratings
Audience reception is largely positive, with many praising the animation, sound, and emotional depth. However, some...
8.8
5
Artland · 2014 · 115,812 ratings
Mushishi Zoku Shou 2nd Season is widely praised for its atmospheric storytelling, philosophical themes, and high...
8.7
6
LAN Studio · 2021 · 185,746 ratings
Overall, the audience response to Shiguang Dailiren is overwhelmingly positive. The show is praised for its unique...
8.7
7
Kyoto Animation · 2010 · 327,549 ratings
The Disappearance of Haruhi Suzumiya is overwhelmingly praised as a masterpiece that surpasses the original series. ...
8.6
8
Kinema Citrus · 2017 · 829,211 ratings
Made in Abyss is a visually stunning and captivating adventure anime with a dark underbelly. While praised for its...
8.6
9
OLM · 2021 · 247,556 ratings
Odd Taxi is a highly regarded anime praised for its intricate mystery, realistic characters, and snappy dialogue. While...
8.6
10
Madhouse · 2010 · 155,807 ratings
The audience is divided on Yojouhan Shinwa Taikei. Some viewers praise its unique storytelling, artistic style, and...
8.5
11
CloverWorks · 2019 · 1,386,888 ratings
The audience is divided on "Yakusoku no Neverland." While many praise the initial episodes for their suspense and...
8.5
12
B.CMAY PICTURES · 2021 · 34,597 ratings
The final season of Mo Dao Zu Shi is met with mixed feelings. While the series is praised for its art, characters, and...
8.5
13
B.CMAY PICTURES · 2025 · 67,798 ratings
Audience reviews are divided, with many anime-only viewers finding the initial episodes confusing due to rapid...
8.5
14
Bones · 2023 · 117,977 ratings
Audience sentiment is largely positive, praising the action, suspense, and plot twists. However, some viewers are...
8.5
15
Production I.G · 2002 · 171,747 ratings
Overall, "Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex" is highly praised for its complex story, well-developed characters,...
8.4
16
ufotable · 2008 · 138,995 ratings
Audience reviews are largely positive, praising the film's complex narrative and high production values. Some find the...
8.4
17
Orange · 2017 · 217,817 ratings
Houseki no Kuni is praised for its innovative CGI animation, unique world-building, and philosophical themes. However,...
8.4
18
Studio M2 · 2023 · 107,703 ratings
Audience sentiment is largely positive, praising the story's depth and emotional impact, as well as the quality of the...
8.4
19
OLM · 2022 · 285,193 ratings
Summertime Render is a well-received anime praised for its intriguing story, excellent animation, and engaging...
8.4
20
Production I.G · 1995 · 370,722 ratings
Ghost in the Shell is widely praised for its groundbreaking animation, philosophical depth, and immersive cyberpunk...
8.3