From Old Country Bumpkin to Master Swordsman Season 2
7.2
Quality Score
0.47 (Positive)
Audience Mood
6 / 10
Controversy
25,165
MAL Ratings
Synopsis — from MyAnimeList
Second season of Katainaka no Ossan, Kensei ni Naru.
Audience Consensus
Audience opinion is divided, largely centering on the main character's personality. Many appreciate Beryl's mature portrayal and the 'slow life' aspects, finding the animation and supporting cast strong. However, a significant portion of viewers find his self-deprecating nature intensely frustrating and the pacing too slow, leading to a polarized viewing experience.
Strengths
- The main character, Beryl, is a compelling and likable adult protagonist whose growth and struggles resonate with viewers.
- The supporting cast and their individual development are well-handled, offering depth beyond the main character.
- The animation and art style, particularly the blend of 2D and CGI during fight scenes, are praised as good to excellent, with some finding it an improvement over the first season.
- The 'slow life' elements, focus on meals, and the found family dynamic between Beryl and Mewi are highlighted as strengths, creating a comfortable and enjoyable viewing experience.
- The fight choreography, focusing on strategy and experience rather than just power, is noted as a positive aspect.
- The story offers a refreshing take on an adult protagonist dealing with adult problems, distinguishing it from typical power fantasy isekai.
- Season 2 is seen by many as a solid continuation that builds upon Season 1, finding its identity and improving in several aspects.
Weaknesses
- The main character's persistent self-deprecation and 'dense' nature are a significant point of annoyance for some viewers, dragging down the narrative.
- The pacing can be too slow or repetitive for some, making certain arcs feel drawn out or lacking in payoff.
- While generally praised, the CGI in fight scenes can still be jarring for some viewers, and the animation quality can be inconsistent.
- The plot can sometimes feel simplistic, with plot holes or contrivances used to advance the story, particularly regarding the antagonist in the final arc.
- Romantic developments are minimal or non-existent, leaving some viewers unsatisfied.
- Despite character growth, some feel Beryl hasn't fundamentally changed much, and certain plot points lack sufficient development or payoff by the season's end.