The Stories of Girls Who Couldn't Be Magicians
Synopsis
From a young age, Kurumi Mirai has aspired to become a magician. Driven by her ambition, she has spent her childhood preparing to join the prestigious Rettoran Academy of Magic. Although Kurumi excels in the selection exam, her dream is crushed when she is not chosen for the elite magic class. Admitted to the standard class at the academy instead, Kurumi soon befriends Maki Kumiiru, her new roommate; and Yuzu Edel, another girl unhappy with her placement. However, to everyone's surprise, their homeroom teacher, Minami Suzuki, promises to teach the class magic anyway. Although skeptical at first, the girls start to believe that this may be their second chance at realizing their dreams and becoming wonderful magicians. [Written by MAL Rewrite]
Audience Consensus
The audience is largely disappointed with Mahoutsukai ni Narenakatta Onnanoko no Hanashi. While the art style receives praise, the plot, characters, and world-building are heavily criticized. Many feel the show failed to capitalize on its potential, resulting in a mediocre and forgettable experience, although some viewers found it enjoyable despite its flaws.
Strengths
- Unique watercolor art style and backgrounds
- Charming character designs by Lily Hoshino
- Catchy opening theme by PuffyAmiYumi
Weaknesses
- Weak and convoluted plot with irrelevant elements
- Underdeveloped and bland characters
- Poor worldbuilding and magic system
- Slow pacing and lack of character growth