Is It Wrong to Try to Pick Up Girls in a Dungeon? II: Is It Wrong to go Searching for Herbs on a Deserted Island?
Synopsis — from MyAnimeList
When Bell Cranel and the rest of Hestia Familia receive a quest to retrieve rare medicinal herbs from a deserted island, they decide to use the opportunity as a vacation to recover from the recent events. Upon their arrival, the situation quickly escalates, as the girls start quarreling for Bell's attention. However, with the unexpected appearance of a familiar face and other strange occurrences beginning to happen on the island, the group must find a way to endure the abrupt hardships.
Audience Consensus
The audience is deeply divided on this OVA. While some fans appreciate it as a fun, lighthearted break with enjoyable character moments and decent animation, a significant portion views it as a nonsensical, repetitive waste of time that relies too heavily on shallow fan service. The polarizing nature stems from its departure from the main series' tone and its questionable narrative choices.
Strengths
- Enjoyable character interactions and chemistry in a laid-back setting.
- Visually appealing animation and beautiful scenery.
- Provides a refreshing, lighthearted break from the main series' heavier themes.
Weaknesses
- The plot is nonsensical, repetitive, and logic-destroying, feeling like a waste of time.
- Over-reliance on fan service that detracts from any potential humor or narrative.
- The ending is abrupt and confusing, with a poorly resolved "dream or reality?" trope.