Her Blue Sky
Synopsis — from MyAnimeList
High school student Aoi Aioi lives with her elder sister, Akane, after a tragic accident took their parents away 13 years ago. Because Akane has since been taking care of her single-handedly, Aoi wants to move to Tokyo after her graduation to relieve her sister's burden and pursue a musical career, inspired by Akane's ex-boyfriend Shinnosuke "Shinno" Kanamuro. Shinno was part of a band until he left for Tokyo to become a professional guitarist after the sisters' parents passed away, and he was never to be seen again. One afternoon, while Aoi practices her bass in a guest house, she gets startled by the 18-year-old version of Shinno from 13 years ago! As if by coincidence, the current 31-year-old Shinno also returns to the town, but he has changed drastically. There are now two Shinno's in existence, but why is the Shinno from the past present? Sora no Aosa wo Shiru Hito yo revolves around these four individuals as they confront their inner feelings toward each other and make decisions that will affect their lives from here on out.
Audience Consensus
Audience opinion is significantly divided on the film's narrative execution, with many praising its character depth, dialogue, and visual artistry. However, a substantial portion of viewers found the plot rushed, the supernatural elements unnecessary, and the ending abrupt, leading to a polarizing reception despite the acknowledged strengths in animation and thematic resonance.
Strengths
- Beautiful and detailed animation, especially character movements and expressions.
- Strong, naturalistic, and humorous dialogue, particularly in character interactions.
- Well-developed characters who act and feel realistic for their age.
- Resonant themes of regret, lost dreams, and sibling love.
- Atmospheric and soaring soundtrack that enhances the melancholic mood.
Weaknesses
- Story pacing issues, with a rushed or underdeveloped plot, especially in the third act.
- Inconsistent tone and atmosphere, shifting between slice-of-life, supernatural mystery, and romance.
- The supernatural/time travel element feels unnecessary or poorly integrated for some.
- Abrupt or unsatisfying ending, with plot threads left unresolved or relegated to post-credit scenes.
- Lack of focus on music despite being a central theme, with the music itself being considered bland by some.