Tree in the Sun
Synopsis
A story set in the mid-1800's about a young doctor who has been trained in Western-style medicine and a young samurai who is trying to live up to the old traditions of his class and culture. The story is actually based upon real people - the doctor, Ryo-an, was Tezuka's great grandfather. During the Second Year of Ansei (1855) in Edo's Koishigawa are two young men, Manjiro Ibutani and Ryoan Tezuka. Ibutani is a low-ranking samurai who is a gifted swordsman and has a straightforward and strong sense of justice. Tezuka has a more carefree attitude. He has an eye for the ladies, but he is passionate about becoming a doctor. The two opposite characters come of age during the backdrop of the turbulent end of the Tokugawa Period (1600-1868 CE). (Source: AnimeNfo)
Audience Consensus
Overall, 'Hidamari no Ki' is viewed as a thoughtfully crafted historical drama with strong characters and a compelling narrative, set against the backdrop of a transforming Japan. While some find the pacing slow and the themes familiar, many appreciate its detailed animation, evocative music, and respectful portrayal of historical events. Despite some problematic content, viewers find the series to be a hidden gem worth watching.
Strengths
- Strong character development, particularly the contrast and growth of the two leads.
- Accurate and respectful depiction of historical events and the transition of Japan during the end of the Tokugawa Shogunate.
- Beautiful and detailed animation, especially the backgrounds and character designs, characteristic of the cel era.
- Evocative and well-integrated orchestral music, enhancing emotional moments.
- Exploration of complex themes such as cultural change, personal beliefs, and class struggle.
Weaknesses
- Pacing may be slow for modern audiences used to faster narratives.
- Some characters are underdeveloped and their arcs are left unresolved.
- Thematic elements, while well-executed, may feel familiar due to similarities with other historical fiction works.
- The endings being rock songs, a tonal mismatch
- Instances of sexual abuse are depicted, which some viewers may find disturbing or unnecessary.